Para ver este documento en español, oprima aquí.

SUN SENTINEL

A Political Island, Puerto Rico Enjoys Economic Links to United States

by Doreen Hemlock

January 24, 1999
©Copyright 1999 KRTBN Knight Ridder Tribune Business News

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico --When Hurricane Georges slammed the Dominican Republic and Haiti last fall, those cash-strapped nations foundered, anxious for financial help from abroad.

But when Georges pounded the bustling U.S. commonwealth of Puerto Rico , the economy instead got a short-term boost. So many billions of dollars flowed from the federal government and U.S. insurance companies that construction boomed. Stores sold TVs, appliances and home furnishings fast. Factories rebounded. Virtually all hotels reopened in time for the Christmas season.

While Puerto Ricans remain split over whether they want to become a U.S. state, their island's speedy recovery from Hurricane Georges shows a paradox: When it comes to the economy, Puerto Rico is practically a state already.

Integration into the U.S. system -- including the use of the U.S. dollar, U.S. interest rates and U.S. bond markets -- helps keep Puerto Rico 's economy humming along with 3 percent annual growth, while many nations in Latin America and the Caribbean now struggle to grow at all.

And that integration also is a key reason that Puerto Rico consistently ranks among the top business partners for Florida, with multibillion-dollar trade yearly and major operations for such diverse companies as Miami-based fast-food chain Burger King and Boca Raton-based alarm system maker Sensormatic Electronics.

"We operate in Puerto Rico just as in any part of the United States," said a spokeswoman for American Airlines, the dominant carrier to the island. "Differences in requirements are like those between Miami or Dallas or San Francisco."

The resemblance to the United States is obvious right from the airport.

Ramps for the disabled, as required by U.S. law. Federally funded expressways and highway signs. Miami-style traffic. But the similarities go far deeper:
-- In retail, U.S.-style malls abound. Puerto Rico has the highest density of Burger Kings worldwide. It hosts the world's largest J.C. Penney, spanning 350,000 square feet, and will soon host the first Macy's outside the continental United States. Sears at Plaza Las Americas mall in the San Juan area sells more than any other Sears store in the world.
-- In finance, Puerto Rico sells its government bonds on the U.S. municipal bond market, with buyers eligible for exemptions from federal, state and local taxes. Credit ratings have remained stable despite financial turmoil that has hit hard at Latin America and the Caribbean since late 1997.
-- In real estate, housing sales are booming -- as in the 50 states, thanks to rock-bottom interest rates on mortgages, often backed by federal government programs such as Fannie Mae.

It's little surprise then that Puerto Rico has been enjoying the fruits of the longest peacetime economic expansion in U.S. history. The island "has mirrored the U.S. economic turnaround since 1991," noted Standard & Poor's. The credit rating agency assigned an "A" rating for Puerto Rico to issue $4 billion in municipal bonds last month.

To be sure, the island known in the 1940s as "the poorhouse of the Caribbean" still has far to go economically to reach the level of the average U.S. state. Per-capita income today is about $8000 a year, about half the level of Mississippi, the poorest state. Unemployment is about 13 percent, historically low for Puerto Rico -- but more than twice the U.S. average. And growth rates similar to U.S. levels are not sufficient for Puerto Rico's economy to reach the income levels of average states.

"The private sector is clear that 3 percent growth is not good enough," said William Riefkohl, executive director of the Puerto Rico Manufacturers Association. "There are some economies in Latin America that have been growing faster than us, like Argentina. And 3 percent won't close the gap with the U.S."

Early this decade, few analysts would have predicted today's smooth sailing for the commonwealth of 3.8 million residents -- or for the U.S. economy, for that matter.

Three years ago, when the U.S. government still posted budget deficits, Congress decided to phase out tax breaks for U.S. manufacturers in Puerto Rico -- part of a plan to raise new tax revenue and curb what some called "corporate welfare." Many analysts predicted doom for Puerto Rico 's manufacturing-based economy.

The phase-out has undeniably hurt. Manufacturing is Puerto Rico's lifeblood, accounting for about 40 percent of the economy -- a bigger share than in the United States or most European nations. Puerto Rico is home to operations for most of the world's major pharmaceutical companies, producing about half the prescription drugs sold in the States -- including the infamous, sex-enhancing Viagra made in Pfizer's plant in Barceloneta.

But without federal tax breaks, few new manufacturers are setting up factories in Puerto Rico today, opting instead for lower-wage sites such as Mexico or tax havens near European markets, such as Ireland. Some factories have closed amid global competition, including Motorola's 1,500-worker pager plant in Vega Baja. And while some companies are expanding -- drug maker Searle, for example, is investing $200 million to boost facilities -- that growth cannot offset manufacturing losses.

Overall, manufacturing employment in Puerto Rico dropped by more than 7,000 jobs in the 12-month period ended October, to 140,000 jobs. Most losses were in apparel and electronics assembly, in line with trends on the U.S. mainland, island officials said.

Still, the administration led by Gov. Pedro Rossello has been able to keep the economy growing, partly through massive public works, including the $300 million Superaqueduct water pipeline and $1 billion-plus Urban Train project, both under way. Spending on roads and other infrastructure rose 70 percent to $1.7 billion during Rossello's first term that ended in 1997, said Carlos Vivoni, secretary for economic development.

Much of the financing came from the U.S. sources -- both from federal grants and loans and from sales on U.S. bond markets.

The government also offered new programs to boost and diversify the economy, including expanded local tax breaks for factories, tax cuts for companies that go public on U.S. stock markets and more promotions to attract hotel developers.

"The big question is whether the government can continue to invest in public works at the rate it's been, until the new incentives and new policies kick in," said economist Joaquin Villamil, president of economic consulting firm Estudios Tecnicos in San Juan. "I'm optimistic it can."

Hurricane Georges offered an unexpected boost to the government-backed construction effort. The Sept. 21 storm -- the worst to hit Puerto Rico in 70 years -- caused more than $3 billion in damage and lost production. It destroyed or seriously damaged about 50,000 homes, or 4 percent of total housing, government officials said.

Now, the Rossello administration proposes to offer incentives for private companies to build up to 50,000 homes on land that the Puerto Rico government would donate, tapping federal funds for the five-year project -- as states would, Vivoni said.

Long term, Rossello and others in his pro- statehood party dream of a day when Puerto Rico would not just resemble a state economically --but actually be the 51st star on the U.S. flag.

"Statehood is a development tool," claimed economic czar Vivoni. "It's not just because we'd get more federal funds. It's for the perception of stability that comes with being a state. Statehood would mean even more business and investment."


Self-Determination Legislation | Puerto Rico Herald Home
Newsstand | Puerto Rico | U.S. Government | Archives
Search | Mailing List | Contact Us | Feedback